News
October 14, 2026

Data Gap or Data Mess

The New Challenge Facing Sustainable Finance‍

Xavier Leroy, Head of ESG, EthiFinance Group – October 2026

Sustainable finance is running up against a familiar obstacle: access to reliable, comparable and usable data. While traditional finance relies on regulated, standardised and audited information, ESG analysis and non-financial reporting still too often depend on data that is incomplete, inconsistent or difficult to verify.

This “data gap” takes many forms: missing information, non-comparable data, reliance on uncertain proxies, or indicators available for some asset classes but absent for others. The gaps are particularly acute in private markets, real assets, SMEs and emerging markets. They also affect complex areas such as biodiversity, human rights, Scope 3 emissions and the real-world impact of investments.

Breaking through this data barrier is essential. Without sufficiently robust information, sustainable finance risks misallocating capital. Better-quality data, by contrast, would enable it to fulfil its role in transforming the economy.

A Bottomless Pit?

The paradox is striking: For more than a decade, the ESG data provider landscape has expanded rapidly, bringing increasingly sophisticated, technology-driven and specialised solutions to the market. Yet the gap between the data required and the data available continues to widen.

This tension reflects the rapid expansion of sustainable finance. Once focused primarily on large listed companies, for which information is public and readily accessible, it now spans a far broader universe. It has also embraced new approaches, from thematic strategies and just transition investing to impact finance. As ambitions expand, data needs are becoming both greater and more complex.

The very nature of non-financial information adds to the challenge. Measuring a decarbonisation pathway, assessing exposure to social controversies or evaluating the quality of governance is far less straightforward than recording revenue or a debt ratio. Despite progress in reporting standards, frameworks remain fragmented across jurisdictions, making the consolidation of global portfolios a complex undertaking.

This is compounded by a less supportive political environment. The backlash against sustainable finance — most visible in the United States, but also perceptible in Europe as well — is weighing on the availability of non-financial data. The European Omnibus Directive adopted in 2025 illustrates this retreat: it significantly reduces both the number of companies subject to non-financial reporting — to less than 80% of the scope initially envisaged — and the volume of data they are required to disclose.

The Institutional Investor’s Data Challenge

For institutional investors, this has become a major operational challenge. Insurers, banks and pension funds manage global portfolios spanning multiple asset classes and jurisdictions. They need reliable, comparable data across all these asset classes to steer their investments and meet their regulatory obligations. The challenge is particularly acute in private equity and private debt, whose share of portfolios continues to grow.

To make matters worse, the asset managers to which institutional investors delegate their mandates often rely on different providers, generating fragmented, non-comparable information that is difficult to consolidate.

The consequences are highly tangible: difficulties complying with certain investment policies, reputational or legal risks, fund downgrades, and rising costs associated with multi-sourcing, data cleansing and direct outreach to issuers. This is therefore not merely a technical issue: it goes to the very heart of how sustainable finance is managed — and how much it costs to implement.

When More Data Isn’t Better Data

The accumulation of ever more specialised and granular data is not necessarily the solution. It can create the illusion of better coverage while further fragmenting information and obscuring significant disparities in quality and relevance.

Sustainable finance does not need more data; it needs better data. That requires three priorities.

Focus, first: prioritising a more limited set of indicators that are genuinely available, verifiable and usable across entire portfolios.

Materiality, next: distinguishing the information that truly matters according to sector, asset class and investment objective.

Integration, finally: connecting different types of data to build a coherent view across global portfolios.

After a decade of rapid expansion, sustainable finance is entering a new phase of maturity. Its next leap forward will not come from an inflation of indicators, but from data that is better selected, verified, standardised and comparable.

Biography of the author

Xavier Leroy, Head of ESG at EthiFinance

Based in Paris, Xavier brings more than 30 years of experience in financial markets and leads the development of the Group's ESG offering.

‍

‍

Resources

More news

Explore related insights and analysis